Home | Newsletter | Penalty Pass

Penalty Pass

West opens the bidding and partner places a takeout double, telling us to choose a different suit.

But West's suit is also our best suit - we don't want to choose a different suit! What should we do?

Penalty Pass in Bridge

After partner's double, what do you do?

Pass
Bid 1NT
Bid 2♣
Bid 2
Redouble
Though diamonds are our best suit, we don't want to bid 2. West would have a field day! The best solution is to ignore partner's request and simply pass. (God bless you jokers who selected "Redouble")

Thank you to our esteemed Royal member @Edgar for sending in this hand. We're so pleased to have you in the club.

Want to play more?

Royal members get unlimited daily hands & all tutorial videos.

USD $ 10 / month + tax.

Cancel anytime, for any reason.

Read More

As everyone plays the daily hands, let's look for any other hands that call for a penalty pass. Questions of comments?

Comments

Sockstevens
pass
aqvakul
aqvakul says:
pass, with 6 diamonds and short in the majors there is no big contract.
Nelram
Nelram says:
Pass. Number of cards+honors in this suit (10 counts as an honor) +level of contract =/>9. This hand 6+2+1. I played it and got 800!
6+2+1
EnnaSarp
EnnaSarp says:
Bid 2 D and kept 5. Gave away only Ace and another Diamond. Spade finesse worked twice. Scored King of Clubs by playing low from hand, and discarded other club losers on Hearts and Spades, but had to give away to Jack of Diamonds. Wonder what would have happened if I had bid 5D!!!
Loughderg123
One of the jokers!!!
Delta
Delta says:
-500
EasyRider194
Surprised with your recommendation, so I'll have to think more deeply about it. Partner could've had massive points. Having been chastised in the past for passing a similar hand, I bid 1 NT and made 8. Really appreciate this site. Thanks guys
Baygon2014
When I play bridge I ask the question whether I or my partner should be in control of the auction. In this instance south should take control for you have all the information you need. Clearly West and South hold most of the diamonds. North must have an opening hand and one would expect that North would have the other three suits covered - the only question is whether or not North has sufficient control in the other suits to make 3nt a realistic option. You also know that slam is not on for otherwise North would have made a suit bid. So you are faced with two options: pass or bid 3nt. The reason for 3nt bid is that you know game is not on in any f the three other suits and you do not want to risk getting caught in an auction where you end up playing game in one of the other suits. So if 3nt is your preferred contract then bid it. You will find that 3nt makes and scores you 600 ,but....1 diamond doubles nets 800! So the pass is the best bid.
JBrown
JBrown says:
Thank you guys I have always wanted to know how to handle that bid.
Dcsk
Dcsk says:
I passed but the 3NT is an interesting one
I’ll try it
Dcsk
Dcsk says:
3NT makes !
heatherte1
Hi.does the decision change for acol players. The system I learnt, 5 card majors. 1D/C shows longest suit 12+ points. Diamonds could be 3 or 4. I do get confused as you can see.
jlpurdie
jlpurdie says:
Thanks Graeme. I can remember playing something similar many years ago when my mother was teaching me bridge. I passed and Mum told me off as it was a take out double. The opposition smiled. When they went down the opposition told me off as I should have bid as it was a take out double. Mum smiled.
Gesher
Gesher says:
Not helpful!West opened 1NT, so cant really practice the penalty x!
TriciaCallow
I was confused, because I play weak NT so W opens 1NT and Partner's X is a penalty anyway. But it does show a lot of HCPs.
So once I'd de-confused myself, I tried Pass, 2, 3 and 5 and 5 got the best result - game bid & made.
sbc4646054
Passed . N/ S scored 800
SquarePeg61
Passed. E/W ended up in 1NTX and made their seven tricks.
Poppingpopcorn
A bid similar to this caused ructions at my club recently & certain players were adamant that the double had to be adhered to, & the doubles ptn ( me) had to takeout. I did then what I would do now, & passed. The takeout double passed becomes a penalty double.
Poppingpopcorn
Just played the hand for a score of 1100. To us. The bidding went - west. 1 diamond. Ptn. Double. All else passed.
jnfsaraiva
None of your's. Would preempt with 3 Dimonds
Log in to comment